As many of you already know I am a fan of American Idol. I don’t really watch TV much at all during the year, except this cheesy reality show, and then I’ve averaged almost every other year (I don’t always find the contestant’s interesting enough to warrant spending time in front of the television). This year was one of my seasons to watch.
From about the top 12 in the competition one contestant caught my attention. I’ve been rooting (and voting) for him all season, and he happens to be in the top two now, with the deciding performances happening tonight. He’s been referred to as smug and cocky by some as the competition has progressed, though I haven’t been of that opinion about him. After all, who would Mick Jagger, Steven Tyler, or any other good rocker be without a little attitude? They’d be really boring if you ask me. Kind of like the other contestant in the top 2 this year. Great voice, but absolutely no stage presence and no personality.
Yes, you guessed it…my pick for American Idol this season is David Cook. He’s a talented singer, musician, and songwriter, come to find out. He’s been playing the bar circuit for several years, and even put out his own solo CD (not under contract by any label…totally independent) before his appearance on American Idol. There has been some controversy surrounding his choices for songs, some of which were arranged by others, though actually credit was always given. AI seems to like controversy…it makes for better TV that way…but I think the public is smart enough to figure it all out for themselves. What David Cook has done is he’s brought some freshness to an otherwise stale and aging show with his performances of songs that he’s resuscitated from the depths of time, whether by his own arrangement or borrowed from others. Having heard his music and songs he’s written from before American Idol it is apparent to me that this guy is the real deal. He’ll be able to “move units,” whereas his competition may not be able to even have a chance charting on an Adult Contemporary chart.
I hope David Cook is crowned the American Idol this year. I am going to be voting my fingers to the bone for him, for sure. But really, even if he doesn’t win, I predict he will still outsell, and outshine, David Archuleta after all is said and done. He has a great career ahead of him, and I for one will be waiting with great anticipation to hear what he comes up with in the future.
So, tell me, David Cook or David Archuleta? Will you be voting?
Has American Idol jumped the shark?
For a mini-recap of tonight’s show, check out the American Idol Season 7 blog here on Xanga sometime after it airs!








